Old Burial Ground of the Scotchtown Presbyterian Church

A-1 (white marble): Catherine D. Mills 1840-1922

A-2: Alfred Mills, died Aug. 30, 1871, age 31 years, 11 months and 23 days

The Whig Press (Jan. 22, 1862): Alfred H. Mills married Delia H. McWilliams on 2nd of January, Scotchtown at the home of John H. Mills.

A-3 (granite): Charles A. Mills 1888-1916

A-4: Dille, daughter of Alfred H. and Delia K. Mills, died April 21 1868, age 3 years, 5 months

A-5: Harrison Mills 1816-1892 ~ Ophelia K. Mills 1824-1886 ~ Mary E. 1854-1855 ~ H. Denton 1866-1872 ~ Louis R. 1890-1900

Obituary from Goshen Independent Republican, December 27, 1892: “Harrison Mills, Sheriff of Orange County, from 1883 to 1886, died at his home in this village Saturday morning, aged 76 years. The illness which resulted in the death of Mr. Mills was of about ten days duration, but it was only within the last few days that his condition was regarded as dangerous. His end came peacefully and quietly at 7 o'clock Saturday morning. Mr Mills was born in the town of Wallkill, near Bullville, and was the son of Denton Mills. When a young man he loacted on a farm in the town of Crawford where he resided until elected Sheriff in 1883. His wife died in June, 1886. He is survived by five sons, Victor K., of Eustis, Fla.; George H., of Goshen; Lewis R., of Little Rock, Ark.; Charles H., of San Francisco, Cal.; James H., of Ogden, Utah, and by one daughter, Emma F.., wife of Fred Smith, of Goshen. He is also survived by a brother, Nathan J., of Circleville; a half-brother, James M. Mills, of Middletown, and by two sisters, Mrs. Mary Ann White, of the town of Wallkill, and Mrs. Ira H. Coleman of Albany. Few men were more widely known and none more highly esteemed than Harrison Mills, whose genial manners, kindliness and good nature were proverbial, and who had a pleasant word and kindly greeting for all. The extent of his popularity was strikingly manifested by his election as Sheriff by a large majority in this Republican county. Through his ownership of Hambletonian's great son Sweepstakes, and his interest in matters that tended to encourage the breeding of good stock he became widely known among the horsemen all over the county. Notwithstanding his advanced age he had withstood the ravages of time in a remarkable degree and was a remarkably hale and vigourous man up to the time of his last sickness.”

A-6 (marble): Ophelia M., daughter of James W. and Mary M. White, born April 5, 1817,
died Oct. 12, 1867

A-7: William H. O’Dell, born July 1, 1834, died September 11, 1903 ~ wife Lillie J. Sloat,
born June 19, 1834

Bob Brennan, Wallkill: Orange County, New York, Vol. 1, page 49: William O’dell’s father was Daniel.

A-8: James M. Puff, died March 1, 1888, age 29 years, 9 months, 24 days

A-9 (soldier monument): James Sloat, Co. E 124th NY Infantry

New York State Adjutant General's Report: Age 19 years, Enlisted August 13, 1862, at Crawford, to serve three years; mustered in as private, Co. E, September 5, 1862; promoted sergeant, September 1, 1864; mustered out with company, June 3, 1865, near Washington, D.C.

A-10: Mary Owen, wife of Rhaddeus Brown, died June 24, 1829

A-11 (3 foot stones)

A-12: Annie S., died August 3, 1871 ~ Mary A., died September 22, 1873
Children of Margaret & John Frame

A-13: [?], son of Chauncy & Jennie Knapp, died August 13, 1887, age 3 years 17 days

A-14: Willie D., son of David and Hattie Lemon, 10 months 19 days
Sleep on sweet babe and take thy rest

A-15: In memory of Rachel Currie, wife of William A. Wallace, who departed this life April 16, 1863, in the 70th year of her age

A-16 (square granite stone): James M. McWilliams, August 25, 1807 - January 17, 1888 ~ Wife, Irene Little 1813-1890 ~ Isaac L. McWilliams 1849-1871 ~ Frances H. McWilliams 1858-1944

Bob Brennan, Wallkill: Orange County, New York, Vol. 1, page 46: James M. McWilliams was the son of John M. McWilliams.

Nancy McWillaims Bible: James Miltom McWillaims married Jane Little March 15, 1832.

A-17: Jane Purdy, died July 4, 1850, 59 years of age
Be ye also ready in such an hour as ye think not, the son of man cometh

B-18: Margaret, wife of William McMonagle, died April 3, 1879 ~ William B. McMonagle, died February 12, 1853. His remains lie at Burr Oaks, Michigan.

B-19: Father, William McMonagle, died November 1, 1842, age 74 ~ William B. McMonagle, died February 12, 1853

B-20 (small marble): Freddie G., son of Thomas & Mary Coleman, died January 8, 1852

B-21: In memory of John Tears, died August 10, 1840, age 79 years, 6 months, 22 days

B-22: In memory of Catherine, wife of John Tears, died March 28, 1851,
age 82 years 6 months 11 days

B-23: In memory of Amelia, wife of Lewis Simmons, daughter of John & Catherine Tears, died December 1827, age 20 years 18 days

B-24: In memory of Andrew Tears, died February 26, 1850, age 63 years 2 months

B-25: In memory of Sarah, wife of Andrew Tears, died Feb. 11, 1832, age 61 years 1 month 9 days

B-26: Thomas Bull, son of Abner & Maria Bull, died Sept. 3, 1891, age 59 years 7 months 5 days

B-27: Sarah Elizabeth, daughter of Abner & Maria Bull, died Aug. 10, 1860,
age 37 years 8 months 9 days

B-28: Abner Bull, died September 2, 1857
He enjoyed God's blessing and felt his corrections

Teaching a household who looked up to him
That which is strongest in human sight may be
destroyed by the beath of the Lord
Fairer are the smiles of one we love than all the
[?]. In nature ample sway.
Maria, wife of Abner Bull, died in the morning on the 8th day of March in the 86th year of her age

The Whig Press (September 9 & 23, 1857): Abner Bull, son of Daniel who settled Hopewell (what is now the Town of Crawford) in 1781 and grandson of William Bull, died September 2 at the age of 67 years. He leaves 1 son and 4 daughters.

B-29: Memory of Hannah Bull, wife of Augustus Thompson, died September 16, 1845,
age 27 years 26 days

B-30: In memory of Emeline, daughter of Abner and Maria Bull, died October 22, 1846,
age 25 years 7 months 2 days

B-31: In memory of William E., son of William B. & Catherine Hurtin, died November 28, 1850,
age 10 years, 8 months

B-32: Mary C., adopted daughter of Dr. J. & Elsie Hornbeck, who died Jan. 30, 1856, age 18 years
Those that seek me early shall find me
Mary sat at Jesus feet and heard his words
Absent from the body, present with the Lord.

B-33: August Hornbeck, son of Joshua and Elsie Hornbeck, died June 5, 1850, age 25 years.
He that believeth in me though he were dead,
Yet shall he live
There is aworld above where parting is unknown
A long eternity of love
Formed for the good alone,
and faith behold the dying here,
translated to the glorious sphere.

B-34: Elsie H. Hornbeck, May 28, 1867, age 67 years, 7 months, 23 days
I shall be satisfied when I awake with thy
likeness. Through suffering unto life.

Kenneth Edward Hasbrouck, The Hasbrouck family in America (typescript, 1985), page 108: ELSIE HASBROUCK, b. 11-5-1797, bp. 10-5; d. 5-29-1867 @ 67-7-23 (Scotchtown Cem.); m. 1-1-1824 Montgomery, Dr. JOSHUA HOORNBECK b. 12-6-1790, d. 1-18-1858, son of ISAAC HOORBECK & ARIANTJE LOW

B-35: Grave of Dr. Joseph Hornbeck, January 18, 1858, age 67 years
Them that sleep in Jesus
Will God bring with him
With us his name shall live
Through long succeeding years
Embalmed with all our hearts can give
Our praises and our tears.

His faith and patience, love and zeal
Should make his memory dear
An Lord do thou those prayers fulfill
He offered for us here.

Here lie the dead in Christ they sleep
Who bore on earth his cross
And from the grave their dust shall rise
In his own image to the skies.

B-36: Oliver Bailey, died December 20, 1866, age 78 years, 2 days ~ Susan M., wife of Oliver Bailey, died July 5, 1873, age 80 years, 1 month, 26 days
She was gathered like a shock of corn fully ripe.

B-37: Margaret, wife of David Kells [?]

B-38: Caroline Corwin, wife of Hesekiah H. Connor, died March 25, 1864, age 46 years,
2 months, 24 days

C-39: Jessie L., born November 15, [?] died January 8, 1891 [?]
John W. Wallace, born January 20, 1851, died January 7, 1897
Julia V. [?]

Bob Brennan, Wallkill: Orange County, New York, Vol. 1, page 56: Jessie L. Wallace died at age 1 month, 24 days. Father was John W. Wallace, mother was Julia V. Scofield.

Obituary from Goshen Independent Republican, January 8, 1897: “Mr. John Wallace, a well known farmer, died at his home near Crystal Run, Thursday morning, after a short illness. Mr. Wallace was a good man, a faithful husband and a fond and devoted father. Deceased was a consistent member of the First Presbyterian Church at this place for the past year. He will be deeply mourned by many friends.”

(old stone) David Winfield, died February 7, 1846 [?]

C-40: Ann E., daughter of Isaac & Elizabeth Kells, died September 13, 1863, age 8 months, 12 days

C-41: Gabriel Myers, died November 2, 1866, 58 years, 7 days

C-42: Sarah A., wife of Gabriel Myers, died April 28, 1885

C-43: Mary L. B. Coleman [?]

C-44: John P. Coleman, born March 7, 1822, died December 6, 1888 ~ Wife, Mary Slaughter, born July 5, 1826, died October 15, 1911 ~ John T. Coleman, born December 12, 1867, died December 12, 1897

C-45: John T. Coleman Jr. [?]

C-46: Children of John T. & Mary L. Coleman:
Hattie, died January 14, 1864, age 1 year, 11 months, 3 days
Fare thee well sweet bud of beauty
Our little darling fare thee well
For thou wert so pure and lovely
In a world like this today

Joseph Slaughter, died February 14, 1868, age 11 years, 1 month and 17 days
Alas death touched the spring of life
No skill or love could save
In childhood's freshest sweetest bloom
He bore him to the grave.

C-47: [?]

C-48: Clarissa, wife of John White, died June 17, 1872, in the 71st year of her age.

C-49: Col. John White, born Februiary 24, 1793, died August 31, 1851

C-50: In memory of Jennett, daughter of Col. John White & Clarissa A. White, died February 21, 1841 [?] age 18 years, 2 months, 6 days.

C-51: William N. White, son of Calvin G. & Harriet W. Sawyer, age 8 months, 15 days

C-52: In memory of Harriet, daughter of C. G. & Hannah Sawyer, died November 1, 1852, age 25 years, 4 months, 15 days

The Whig Press (November 10, 1852): Harriet, daughter of Gen. Calvin G. Sawyer, died of Tuberculosis on November 1, 1852 in Hamptonburg at the age of 26 years

C-53: Frances A., wife of Joel H. Coleman, [died] July 28, 1861, age 23 years, [?], 28 days

The Whig Press (Dec. 30, 1857): Joel H. Coleman of Blooming Grove married Frances, daughter of Gen. C.G. Sawyer of Hamptonburg, October 28 1857

The Whig Press (August 14, 1861): Mrs. F. Alida Coleman, daughter of Gen. C. G. Sawyer, died in Middletown on July 28, age 23 years, 1 month, 28 days

C-54: Harriet W., wife of C. G. Sawyer, died May 7, 1861, age [?], 8 months, 11 days

The Whig Press (May 15, 1861): Harriet, wife of Gen. C. G. Sawyer, died May 7, 1861 in Middletown at the age of 45 years, 9 months, 11 days

C-55: James W. Cash, died February 7, 1865, age 27 years, 2 months, 8 days
So uncertain is life
How important to be ready for death

C-56: H.R.I.P. The mortal part of Rachel Thompson, who departed this life July 16, 1811,
age 5 years, 11 months, 15 days
(Foot Stone) R.T.

C-57: In memory of Jane Sterritt, who departed this life, Dec. 28, 1808, age 4 years, 6 months, 2 days

C-58 (Flat tablet over grave): In memory of Robert Sterritt who departed this life, Feb. 2, 1813, age 39 years, 6 months
Affliction fore a long time bore
Physicians art was vain
Till God did pleafe to give me eafe
and free from my pain

Notes by C. A. Comfort and I. J. Gibbs: Believe Mr. Sterrit came from Ireland. He was interested in Building the Goshen-Wallkill Turnpike and meetings were held at his house in Scotchtown in 1810 and 1811. He had the first store in Scotchtown and only lived 39 years due to some serious illness.

Early Wills of Orange County, NY, vol. 2, page 124: Robert Sterrit’s will, dated June 20, 1810 and probated February 10, 1813, lists his wife Margaret and his son Samuel Morrison Sterrit (minor). Also listed without relationship are Samuel Sterrit, Ezekiel Sterrit, Margaret Loggon, and Joseph Sterrit, all of Donagal, Ireland. Patrick Bodle, Mary Bodle amd Neal McNeagh are listed as witnesses and Robert Wilson and John Thompson are named as executors of his estate.

C-59: Margaret, wife of William Mackinson, died April 16, 1872, age 71 years, 9 months, 12 days

C-60: William Mackinson, died July 2, 1868, age 66 years, 8 months

C-60A: In memory of Agnes Wilson

C-61: In memory of Armstrong, son of Robert & Jane Wilson, died November 26, 1836

C-62: In memory of Jane, wife of Robert Wilson, died Mar. 5, 1829, age 57 years, 11 months, 6 days
Lord as I live I will bless thy name
My King my God of love
My words and joy shall be the same
In the bright world above.

C-63: In memory of Robert Wilson, died June 10, 1841, age 72

C-64: In memory of Oscar S., son of George W. & Adeline Vail, died September 18, 1811,
age 1 year, 2 days
Suffer the little children to come unto me
and forbid them not for such is the kingdom of heaven.

C-65: Lewis A., son of George & Adeline Vail, born December 20, 1833, died [?]

D-66: Lotty Boak, died December 14, 1828, age 25 years, 1 month, 25 days

D-67: John Boak, died December 14, 1828, age 36 years

D-68: Caroline Elizabeth, daughter of John E. & Mary Brewster, died October 5, 1826,
age 2 years, 5 months, 5 days

D-69: Robert Boak, son of John L. [should read John E.] & Mary Brewster, died April 1, 1843,
age 3 years, 3 months, 25 days

D-70: Mary Boak, wife of John Brewster, died March 6, 1870, age 69 years

D-71: John Everett Brewster, died March 1874, age 75 years, 8 months
Yes, the day has been full of labor
But now is the daylight past
And the journey was very toilsome
But the journey is over at last
Safe in the Saviour's presence
And satisfied with his love
Free from earths care and sorrows
Our father rests in his home

D-72: Robert Osburn, died March 16, 1820, age 56 years, 8 months, 12 days

D-73: Mary Osburn, died June 11, 1819, age 48 years, 9 months, 6 days

D-74: Mary Jane, daughter of Jonathan & Sarah Osburn, died March 6, 1848,
age 28 years, 11 months, 13 days

D-75: Susan G. Osburn, died February 16, 1858, age 18 years, 6 months, 26 days

D-76: Sarah Jane, daughter of David & Catherine Sloan, died April 29, 1808, age 1 year, 9 months

D-77: Sarah, wife of Jonathan Osburn, died June 21, 1871, age 73 years, 3 months, 5 days

D-78: Jonathan Osburn, died October 11 1856, age 66 years, 8 months, 9 days
My Flesh shall slumber in the ground
Till the last trumpet’s joyful sound
Than burst the chain with sweet surprise
And in my Saviuor’s image rise

D-79: Sally Crane, died November 7, 1838, age 45 years, 11 months, 7 days
The months of affliction are oer
The days and nights of distress
We see her in anguish no more
She gained her happy release.

D-80: Enos Ayres, died June 5, 1848, age 40 years, 10 months
[long inscription, unreadable]

D-81: Eleanor Gibb, wife of Enos Ayres, died Feb. 29, 1900, age 77 years, 4 months, 27 days

E-82: Jennet Ruth, wife of George Goldsmith, daughter of Jason & Jennie Corwin, died Feb. 15, 1857
age 34 years, 2 months, 20 days

E-83: George V. Goldsmith, died February 1, 1860, age 40 years, 11 months

Federal Mortality Records from the 1860 Census: Died in February at the age of 38 from an affection of the liver lasting 5 months. He was a retired farmer and a widower.

E-84: David Hawkins, died February 12, 1868, age 70 years, 10 months, 28 days
Jesus can make a dying bed
Feel soft as downy pillows are
While on his breast I lay my head
And breathe out my life sweetly there
O thou who presence my soul also delights
On whom in affliction I call
My comfort
by day and my song in the night
My Jesus, my Saviour, my all.

E-85: In memory of Margaret Hawkins, died April 12, 1866, age 71 years, 7 months

E-86: Samuel S. Hawkins, died June 9, 1851, age 43 years, 10 months, 18 days

E-87 (stone broken in half): [?]

E-88: Elizabeth, wife of Oliver Hawkins, died September 21, 1842, age 72 years

Charles C. Coleman, Early Marriage Records of the First Presbyterian Church at Goshen: Oliver Hawkins married Elizabeth McCormick on August 18, 1793.

E-88A: Rachel, wife of John Brown, [?]

E-89: Catherine, daughter of Rachel, [?]

E-90: John Brown Jr., died June 25, 1872, age 76 years, 10 months

E-91: Henry C., son of Ann Brown, age 2 years, 1 month, 10 days

E-92: Ann, wife of S. W. Brown, died March 2, 1854, age 62 years

E-93: In memory of Eleanor [?]

E-94: In memory of Eleanor, wife of Jacob H. Hawkins, and daughter of Felix Randall, died March 30, 1835, age 25 years. Just before she breathed her last, she expressed her strong consolation in the language-D-Watt
Jesus can make a dying bed
Fell soft as downy pillows are
While on his breast I lean my head
And breathe out my life sweetly there

[rest of inscription is unreadable but must be similar to E-84]

E-95: In memory of Hannah, wife of Felix Randall, died September 27, 1860, age 93 years

E-96: In memory of Felix Randall, died March 13, 1845, age 79 years
My flesh and hair faileth, but
God is the strength of my heart and my portion
forever. P’s LXXIII, 26
[Psalm 73.26]

E-97: Jacob Randall, died July 23, 1865, age 68 years, 28 days
Blesses are they that die in the name of the Lord.

The Whig Press (July 26, 1865): “ANOTHER OLD CITIZEN GONE – Jacob Randall, Esq., died at his residence in Harlem, N.Y., on Sunday morning, July 23d, of cancer in the stomach, aged 69 years. His funeral will take place at Scotchtown, Tuesday, at 3 o’clock, p.m. Friends and acquaintances are invited to attend. Mr. Randall was a native of this town, having been born near Scotchtown. For many years he kept a hotel at Searsville. When the late Edward L. Welling was made Sheriff, he appointed Mr. Randall Deputy and keeper of the Goshen Jail. He also held several minor offices, in all of which he faithfully and intelligently performed his duty. A few years ago he removed to Illinois, and from thence to New York, where he lived up to the time of his death. Besides being a good citizen and honest man he was an old Whig and a zealous Union man, aiding the Government by the help of two of his sons, who were in the service to put down the Rebellion. Peace to his memory.”

E-98 (white stone): [unreadable, badly broken, possibly wife of Jacob Randall]

E-99: Memory of Catherine, wife of John Lydle, died November 3, 1825, age 62 years.

E-100: John Lydle, died July 7, 1848, age 73 years.

E-101: Jacob, son of Charles & Lettie Mills, born March 31, 1837, died October 1, 1838.

E-102: Charles Wesley Mills, born October 25, 1847, died August 12, 1852

E-103: Charles Mills, died January 31, 1852, age 51 years, 2 months, 28 days

E-104: Hannah T., daughter of Charles & Letty Mills, died September 4, 1865, age 25 years.

E-106: In memory of Nancy, wife of Hiram S. Dunning, and daughter of Samuel & Esther Mills, age 33 years, 7 months, 24 days
She sleeps in Jesus blessed sleep
From which none never wake to weep
A calm and undefiled repose
Unbroken by the last of foes.

E-107 (large monument): Catherine Mills, born October 20, 1788, died January 30, 1851, age 63 years

E-108: In memory of Moses Miller, died August 1, 1855, age 55 years, 6 months, 20 days

E-109: In memory of Emily, wife of Moses Miller, died November 28, 1844, age 44 years, 11 months, 25 days

E-110: Jacob Mills, born December 22, 1746, died February 18, 1841, age 94 years, 1 month, 27 days

F-111: Catherine Denton, wife of Jacob Mills, age 69 years, 2 months, 15 days.

F-112: Jonathan Mills, September 19, 1830, age 55 years

F-113: Jane McCord, reelect of Jonathan Mills, died June 8, 1846, age 67 years, 3 months, 17 days

F-114: Elsie, daughter of Samuel & Marie White, age 3 months, 8 days

F-115 (badly weathered stone): Maria, daughter of Samuel & Maria White

F-115A: Charles, son of Samuel & Maria White, died August 9, 1827, age 3 years, 1 month, 29 days

F-116: Maria, wife of Samuel White, died October 31, 1836, age 37 years, 8 months, 18 days

F-117: Samuel White, born March 4, 1795, died June 4, 1852

F-119: Charity Corwin, wife of Phineas Corwin, who departed this life March 27, 1806, age 51 years, 10 months, 11 days
She lived respected
When dead lamented.

F-120: Phineas Corwin, died June 3, 1851

F-121: Rebekah Corwin, fell asleep 1873

F-122: Sarah Corwin, June 28, 1855, age 30 years, 7 months, 22 days

F-123 (weathered, no inscription)

F-124 (weathered, no inscription)

F-125: Sarah L. [?], daughter of Rev. Ralph & Mary G. Bull, born Milford, Pike County Pennsylvania, died at the same place, June 22, 1840 of scarlet fever after an illness of 70 hours, age 5 [years or months], 5 [months or days].

Moses Bull Family Bible: Ralph Bull was born December 10, 1802, the son of Moses Bull Jr. (1773-1848) and Dolly Moore (1771-1855). He married Mary G. Hollinshead on March 15, 1830.

F-126: In memory of James B., son of Harvey & Caroline McMonagle, died October 3, 1841,
age 2 years, 21 days

Moses Bull Family Bible: Caroline Bull and her sister Catherine were born August 25th, 1808. They were the twin daughters of Moses Bull Jr. (1773-1848) and Dolly Moore (1771-1855). Caroline married Andrew McWilliams on September 15, 1829, and remarried Harvey McMonegal in December of 1836.

Nancy McWillaims Bible: Andrew Mcwilliams, Caroline’s first husband, died March 8th 1830.

F-129: Charles S., son of Daniel & Sarah Jackson, died Dec. 23, 1860,
age 2 years, 4 months, 4 days.

The Whig Press (January 9, 1861): Charles L. Stewart, son of Daniel S. and Sarah E. Jackson, died in New York City on December 23, 1860.

F-130: Ella, daughter of Daniel & Sarah Jackson, died August 2, 1864, age [?]

The Whig Press (August 17, 1864): Ella, daughter of Daniel S. and Sarah E. Jackson, died in Mount Hope on August 7, 1864 at the age of 4 months.

F-131: Aschsah Boak [?]

F-132: James Boak, died May 8, 1851, age 81 years

F-133: James Boak, 1770-1851, Aschsah Faulkner, wife, 1777-1859
Melinda Boak, 1810-1894
Lucinda Boak, 1814, 1895
Arminda E. Boak, 1823-1894

Bob Brennan, Wallkill: Orange County, New York, Vol. 1, page 26: James Boak, father of Melinda, Lucinda and Arminda Boak was born in Ireland.

F-134 (new marble): John W. Harlow, 1821-1895 ~ Mary W. Young, 1827-1866 ~ Mary B. Bull, 1842- ~ Annie F. 1855-1865

Obituary from Goshen Independent Republican, Feb. 19, 1895: “John W. Harlow, age 73 years, died at his home near Crystal Run, Friday night, of general debility. Mr. Harlow was a farmer and was born and always resided on the homestead where he died. He was married to Mary W. Young Nov. 25, 1847. She died March 10, 1863. Two children were born to them, Charles Wellington Harlow, who resides on a farm adjoining his father, and Annia Florence, who died Nov. 16, 1864 at the age of 9 years. Mr. Harlow was married a second time to Mary B. Bull, who with one child, Annie Mary, wife of J.O. Crawford, still survive. Mr. Harlow had been for 26 years a member of the Scotchtown Presbyterian Church.”

Bob Brennan, Wallkill: Orange County, New York, Vol. 1, page 37: John W. Harlow was the son of Stephen and Abigail Harlow.

F-135: Mary W., wife of John W. Harlow, died March 10, 1863, age 35 years, 10 months, 14 days

F-136: Anna F., daughter of J. W. & Mary W. Harlow, died March 6, 1867, age 9 years, 3 months, 21 days.

F-138 (broken stone): John W. Harlow, [?]

F-140: Henry, adopted son of Abraham & Margaret B. Fonda, died at Fortress Monroe, Mar. 5, 1862. He enlisted in the service of his country and after a brief career, fell a good soldier of Jesus Christ.

E. M. Ruttenber and L. H. Clark, History of Orange County, New York, page 483: Henry Fonda, Co. D, 56th; enlisted September 23, 1861

Kenneth E. Hasbrouck, Early Records of Marriages, Dutch Reformed Church, Montgomery, NY: Abraham Fonda of the Town of Wallkill married Margaret Cranse of the Town of Crawford, July 5, 1832.

G-141: Sarah Furgeson, wife of Dennis O’Neil, departed this life June 7, 1883, age 59 years,
11 months, 7 days

G-142: James H. Harlow, born February 26, 1809, died May 26, 1884

Bob Brennan, Wallkill: Orange County, New York, Vol. 1, page 37: James H. Harlow was the son of Stephen Harlow.

G-143: Catherine J. Harlow, born October 20, 1814, died November 11, 1879

G-144: Ellen, daughter of Caleb & Julia Goldsmith, age 21 years, 4 months

G-145: Caleb Goldsmith, died March 23, 1858, age 65 years, 1 month, 8 days

G-146: John, son of William & Sarah Slaughter, died October 16, 1864, age 2 years, 6 months,
15 days

G-147: Henrietta, daughter of William & Sarah Slaughter, died April 23, 1864

G-148: In memory of William W., eldest son of William & Mary Slaughter, died January 25, 1857, age 18 years, 2 months, 26 days
Thy will be done on earth, Oh God as it is in heaven

G-149: In memory of Jane Frances, daughter of William & Mary Slaughter, died April 20, 1845

G-150: Emily Augusta, daughter of William & Mary Slaughter, died June 2, 1846

G-151: Mary M., wife of William H. Slaughter, died March 2, 1849, age 30 years, 1 month, 21 days

G-152: William H. Slaughter, died March 20, 1869, age 51 years, 8 months, 14 days ~ wife Sarah Crawford, born August 11, 1827, died September 15, 1883

G-153: In memory of David Bell, who departed this life September 12, 1822, age 63 years

G-154: Samuel W. Scott, died May 16, 1890, age 35 years ~ Fannie, his wife died January 12, 1885, age 24 years, 11 months, 7 days ~ Catherine W., wife of David B. Scott, died July [?], 1875, age 47 years, 3 days.

G-155: James Reeve, son of David S. & Sarah E. Jackson, died September 26, 1863, age 10 months

G-156: George S. McWilliams, died November 27, 1845, age 33 years, 9 months, 3 days
Wrapt in the shades of death no more
The friendly face we see
Empty, Oh empty, every place
Once filled so well by thee

Nancy McWillaims Bible: George Stewart McWillaims was born Feb. 24, 1812. He married Matilda Randall Dec. 24th 1833.

G-157: Matilda R., wife of George S. McWilliams, died April [?]

G-158: Catherine, daughter of Felix & Hannah Randall, died December 23, 1878

G-159: Nehemiah G. Goldsmith, died April 7, 1873, age 44 years, 10 months, 27 days

G-160: Tribute to the memory of Mary E., wife of Nehemiah G. Goldsmith, born April 15, 1828,
died December 30, 1867

G-161: Sophia S. Whitman, died April 7, 1859, age 61 years, 2 months

G-162: Sarah P., daughter of Nicholas & Tarissa Evertson, age 22 days

G-163: To the memory of Nathan Johnson, who departed this life February 26, 1833,
age 62 years, 2 months, 29 days

G-164: Margaret Toulon, died July 22, 1852, age 92 years, 19 days

The Whig Press (July 28, 1852): Age at death was 96 years. [possible error reading the inscription]

G-165: In memory of William H. Goldsmith, died September 20, 1845, in the 24th year of his age.

G-166: In memory of Phebe, daughter of Moses & Abigail Goldsmith, died January 25, 1839,
age 28 years

G-167: Moses Goldsmith, died March 8, 1811, age 52 years, 1 month, 29 days

G-168: Abigail, wife of Moses Goldsmith, born New Years Day 1792, died January 14, 1874

G-169: In memory of Catherine, daughter of Moses and Dolly Bull, died September 6, 1829,
age 27 years

Moses Bull Family Bible: Catherine Bull and her sister Caroline were born August 25th, 1808. They were the twin daughters of Moses Bull Jr. (1773-1848) and Dolly Moore (1771-1855). Catherine died “Sabbath morning” September 6, 1829. [She must have been 21 years old at the time of death, 21 and 27 appearing very similar on an old tombstone]

G-170: Roda Bull, wife of Hesekiah Connor

Moses Bull Family Bible: Rhoda Bull was born March 1, 1811. She married Hezekiah Connor on September 19, 1833. She died April 1, 1836

G-171: Dolly Moore, reelect of Moses Bull, born June 17, 1771, died May 14, 1855
Looking unto Jesus – Heb. 12.2

G-172: Moses Bull, age 71 years, 21 days

Moses Bull Family Bible, obituary dated by hand May 1848: Died. At Scotchtown, Orange Co., on the 16th inst., in the 75th year of age, MOSES BULL, Jr., after a protracted sickness of about 8 months. His disease was congestion of the lungs, and sever sufferings gradually wore out his strength. He exhibited the patience of the saint, and the confidence of a servant of Christ. Though a plain farmer, his taste for books was remarkable, and he made himself familiar with many volumes of history and biography and general literature.

G-173: Charity Brown [?]

H-174: Nathan Brown, died December 17, 1843, age 41 years, 4 months, 18 days

H-175: Tuthill Brown, January 7, 1817, age 26 years, 11 months, 28 days

H-176: Mary, wife of Duncan Brown, died May 26, 1827, age 63 years, 8 months, 20 days

H-177: Duncan Brown, died January 9, 1816, age 60 years, 3 months, 12 days

H-178: William Brown, [?]

H-179: Effa Brown, died December 5, 1882, age 77 years, 6 months, 16 days

H-179A: In memory of Eunice Mapes, who departed this life, age 59 years, 10 months, 20 days

H-179B (small marble stone): [?]

H-180: In memory of Dorothy, wife of Samuel Millspaugh, died October 1, 1872

H-181: Samuel Millspaugh, died April 10, 1867

Francis C. Millspaugh, The Millspaugh Family in America (1959), p. 105: [son of Adam Millspaugh, J-284] Born Dec. 16, 1783 Hamptonburg, N.Y. Served as a private in Captain Dunning's Co., N.Y. Militia, in the war of 1812. Married (1) Dorothy Brown April 11, 1809 who was born March 29, 1791 and died June 9, 1812 and (2) Dorothy Corwin who was born March 26, 1790 daughter of Eli and Dorothy Horton Corwin, was a sister of Cynthia Corwin and of Jason Corwin, and died Oct. 21, 1872. He taught school and was a farmer living near Wallkill, N.Y. For many years he was an elder in the Presbyterian Church at Scotchtown, N.Y. He died April 30, 1867 and is buried with both wives in the cemetery at Scotchtown.

H-182: Gilbert Brown, died November 10, 1828, son of Samuel & Dolly Millspaugh, age 18 years,
2 months, 2 days
Surviving friends by this you see
From deaths arrests no age is free
Both old and young around me lie
Prepare for death, you to, must die.

H-183: In memory of Dolly Millspaugh, wife of Samuel Millspaugh who departed this life Tuesday, June 9, 1812, age 21 years, 2 months, 11 days

H-184: In memory of Ruth, wife of Jason Corwin, who departed this life April 21, 1806, age 18 years, 10 months, 2 days

H-185: Gilbert Brown, who departed this life September 9, 1806, age 46 years, 10 months, 9 days

H-186 (stone badly broken): Mary, reelect of Gilbert Brown, died November 1, [?], age 62 years, 2 months, 14 days

H-187: Mary Brown, died September 20, 1849, age 82 years, 6 [months or days]

H-188: In memory of William Brown, who departed this life October 20, 1802, age 39 years,
4 months, 9 days

H-189: In memory of John Brown, who departed this life July, 18, 1801, age 84 years, born 1717.

Early Wills of Orange County, NY, vol. 2, page 48: The will of John Brown, dated September 16, 1799 and probated August 4, 1801, lists his wife Charity, his sons William, Duncan and John, his daughters Christian Brown, Mary Brown, Margaret Hulse, Jane Tuthill, Ephey White, Meriem Robins, and his grandsons John (son of William Brown) and Tuthill and Nathan (sons of Duncan Brown). John Durham, Robert McCord, and Lette McCord are listed as witnesses and Andrew McCord and John Cox are named as executors of his estate.

H-190: In memory of Charity Brown, who departed this life October 30, 1814, age 80 years,
5 months, 24 days

H-191: In memory of Martha Lewis, died May 17, 1832, age 68 years, 6 months, 23 days

H-192: In memory of Phebe Smith, wife of Enos Smith, who departed this life May 25, 1810

H-193: In memory of Enos Smith, died October, 3, 1818, age 63 years, 10 months, 24 days

H-194: In memory of Luther Smith, died July 4, 1835, age 53 years, 10 months, 26 days

H-195: In memory of Mary, wife of Luther Smith, died Aug. 18, 1838, age 59 yrs, 2 months, 8 days
Be ye also ready.

H-196: In memory of William Smith, died October 9, 1839, age 28 years
Precious in the sight of the Lord is the death of his saints.

H-197: In memory of Elizabeth, only daughter of Luther & Mary Smith, died November 27, 1839,
age 29 years, 9 months.

H-198: Mary E., wife of John Knapp, died March 12, 18[??], age 25 years, 11 months, 15 days

H-199: Sarah, wife of John McCurdy, died February 8, 1834, age 34 years
John McCurdy, died February 21, 1858, age 67 years, 4 months

H-200: Lorenzo, son of John & Sarah McCurdy, died June 2, 1824, age 7 months, 27 days

H-201: In memory of Sarah Ann, wife of Charles B. Baldwin, died July 9, 1833, age 31 years,
5 [months or days]

H-202: In memory of Charles Baldwin, died January 7, 1847, in the 71st year of his age

H-203: In memory of Julia M., daughter of Charles B. & Sarah Ann Baldwin, died Nov. 12, 1830, age 4 years, 9 months, 8 days

H-204: In memory of Julia Ann, wife of Methuselah Baldwin, died May 11, 1818

H-205: Sacred to the memory of Methuselah Baldwin, who departed this life February 27, 1847,
age 84 years

Notes by C. A. Comfort and I. J. Gibbs: He was the first Pastor of the Scotchtown Presbyterian Church. Quite a large monument, erected by his son-in-law.

H-206: In memory of Methuseleah B., son of Hiram & Jane Parson

H-207: In memory of Methuselah, son of Hiram & Jane Parson, died March 29, 1832, age 5 weeks

H-208: In memory of Julia Sarah, daughter of Hiram & Jane Parson, died February 23, 1826, age 1 year, 9 [months or days]

H-209: In memory of Jane, daughter of Hiram & Jane Parson, died April 27, 1831

H-210: In memory of Jane Harriet, daughter of Hiram & Jane Parson, died January 6, 1832, age 6 months

H-211 (large granite monument): Benjamin Slaughter, died October 4, 1841, age 45 years, 6 months, 4 days ~ Sarah, wife died January 7, 1886, age 85 years ~ Joseph Slaughter, died March 13, 1863, age 31 years, [?] months, 14 days

H-212: Ann, wife of Thomas U. Prichard, died May 18, 1837, age 27 years, 10 months ~
John U. Prichard, died July 30, 1831, age 1 [year or month], 1 day

H-213: Mary S., wife of James Couser, died November 18, 1868

H-214: James S. Couser, July 16, 1856, age 44 years
Dearest husband thou has left us
Here thy loss we deeply feel
But tis God that has bereft us
He can all our sorrows heal

H-215: James Smiley, died October 12, 1866, age 86 years
He trusted in God.

H-216: Agnes, wife of James Smiley, died January 8, 1855, age 70 years

I-217: Hellen Jane, daughter of Joseph & Amelia Slaughter, age 4 years, 10 months, 7 days

I-218: In memory of Isaac Slaughter, died February 16, 1838, age 83 years

I-219 (broad marble slab): In memory of Benjamin Slaughter [same inscription as H-211]

I-224: George H., son of Alexander & Matilda Sloat, died October 1, 1851, age 6 months, 11 days

I-225: Frances Almeda, daughter of Alexander & Matilda Sloat, died September 12, 1857, age 4 years, 3 months, 12 days

I-226 (foot stone): J.A.B.

I-227: In memory of Sarah, wife of William Connor, died June 13, 1813, age 31 years, 6 months,
11 days
My husband dear and children dear
My God had called me home
Remember to, he will send for you
To judgement you must come.

I-228: William Connor died this morning at 7 o’clock, June 30, 1851, age 76 years, 7 months, 17 days

I-229: Elizabeth D., wife of William Connor, died May 14, 1855, of applexia at 7 o’clock in the morning, age 76 years, 8 months, 17 days

I-230: Mary E. Connor, died March 22, 1822, daughter of William & Elizabeth Connor, age 1 year,
1 month, 10 days

I-231: In memory of Elizabeth, daughter of William & Sarah Connor, died Jan. 4, 1835, age 24 years, 4 months, 14 days

I-232: In memory of Hiram Connor, died March 31, 1838, age 37 years, 4 months, 1 day

I-233: Martha Connor, born March 22, 1819, died May 11, 1861

I-234: Andrew McWilliams, died March 2, 1830, age 4 months, 13 days

I-235: R. Allen, son of Nancy McWilliams, died July 12, 1842, age 21 years

I-236: [?]

I-237: John McWilliams, died July 1[3], 1850, age 69 years, 3 months, 18 days

Nancy McWillaims Bible: John McWilliams was the son of John McWilliams and Sarah Haffy who came to America from Scotland and purchased a farm in Scotchtown in 1785. John was born in the Town of Wallkill March 25th, 1781 and married Nancy Stitt Dec. 23 1802.

Federal Mortality Records from the 1850 Census: He died of Consumption after 6 weeks with the illness

I-238: Nancy Stitt, wife of John McWilliams, died March 25, 1870, age 86 years, 3 months, 7 days

Nancy McWillaims Bible: Nancy Stitt was born Feb. 18th 1784 in the Town of Wallkill and married John McWilliams Dec. 23rd 1802.

I-239: In memory of P U A H Gardiner, wife of David R. Arnell, married May 2, 1795, Hopewell Church, died June 16, 1806, age 30 years, 9 months, 6 days

I-240: James & Sarah Miller, James died August 1814, Sarah died Decemer 18, 1856

I-241 (nice marble stone): Samuel I. Miller, died April 1, 1869, age 76 years

I-242: Alexander Miller, died September 3, 1831, age 26 years

I-243: Caroline Miller, born July 7, 1800, died March [?], 1851

I-244: Theodore Houston, died October 20, 1839, age 29 years, 9 months, 23 days

I-245: Samuel Houston, died December 2, 1826, in 18th year of age

I-246: Julia, wife of George Houston, died October 14, 1830, age 52 years

I-247: George Houston, died January 5, 1826, age 62 years

I-248: Jane, wife of George Houston, died November 22, 1800, age 36 years

I-249 (small white stone): [?]

I-250: George H. Houston, died January 11, 1853, age 23 years
Mary Ann, died May 28, 1828, age 4 years
George H. Miller, died July 19, 1853, age 5 months, 4 days

I-251: John G. Houston, died September 10, 1838, age 63 years, 2 days

I-252: Susan, wife of John G. Houston, died January 8, 1849, age 53 years

I-253: George, son of John G. & Susan Houston, died June 30, 1825, age 11 days

I-254: Samuel, son of John & Susan Houston, age 2 months, 11 days

I-255: Samuel Mills, died November 13, 1860, age 84 years, 2 months, 17 days

I-256: Esther Stitt, wife of Samuel Mills, died November 11, 1863, age 76 years, 2 months, 11 days

I-257: In memory of John Stitt Mills, son of Samuel & Esther Mills, died April 5, 1816, age 11 months, 29 days
Dear parents do not weep
I am not dead but hear to sleep
My life was short by this you see
Prepare for death and follow me.

I-258: In memory of Jacob S., son of Samuel & Esther Mills, died Oct. 21, 1822, age 4 yrs, 10 days

I-259: Daughter of Samuel & Esther Mills, died January 30, 1835, age 6 months, 12 days

I-260: Catherine, daughter of Samuel & Esther Mills, died April 10, 1852

I-260A: Elizabeth H. Mills, died September 6, 1822

I-261: Sarah, wife of Hesekiah H. Mills, died March 11, 1830, age 31 years, 7 months, 20 days

I-262: Hesekiah H. Mills, died October 27, 1885, age [?]

I-263: Elizabeth Miller, wife of Hesekiah H. Mills, born June 22, 1797, died October 22, [?]

I-264: Julia A. Swezey, died August 21, 1854, age 28 years, 11 months

I-265: David Swezey, March 31, 1838, age 27 years, 8 months, 22 days

I-266: Fadious Swezey, died December 14, 1865, age 82 years, 8 months, 4 days

I-267: Fanny Swezey, died June 25, 1874, age 85 years, 11 months

I-268: Jonah Miller, died January 20, 1860, age 29 years, 9 months, 8 days
David, only child of Jonah & Esther Miller

Federal Mortality Records from the 1860 Census: He was a farmer and a married man, who died at the age of 30 after a 2 year battle with Consumption.

I-269: Here lies my mother, Mrs. Ann Stevens, died September 19, 1862, age 46 years

I-270: William Wilsons, died October 5, 1859, age 38 years

J-271: Sarah, M., wife of James Clearwater, died March 24, 1885, age 68 years
We miss her

J-272: In memory of Alanson Comfort, died April 8, 1814, age 6 years, 10 months, 25 days
My parents dear weep not for me
When in this yard my grave you see
My time was short and blest was he
That called me to eternity

Notes by C. A. Comfort and I. J. Gibbs: Alanson Comfort was a brother of Charles Alexander Comfort’s grandfather.

J-274: In memory of John White, died Sept. 11, 1839, age 80 years, 9 months, 21 days

Charles C. Coleman, Early Marriage Records of the First Presbyterian Church at Goshen: John White married Effy Brown on March 15, 1792.

J-275: Effie, wife of Major John White, died May 21, 1847, age 77 years, 5 [months or days]

J-276: Clarrissa Millspaugh, wife of Dr. A. W. Millspaugh

J-277: In memory of Adam W. Millspaugh, died September 7, 1844, age 29 years, 3 months, 21 days

J-278: Bettridge, daughter of Major John & Effa White, died May 25, 1838, age 30 years, 4 months, 2 days

J-279: Jennet Baily, wife of Nathaniel Baily, died April 3, 1819, age 21 years, 3 months, 22 days

J-280: Nettridge White, died September 17, 1814, 79 years of her age

J-281: Samuel White, died March 5, 1810, age 86 years
Remember me when this you see
Prepare for death and follow me

Early Wills of Orange County, NY, vol. 2, page 103: The will of Samuel White, dated August 19, 1801 and probated March 30, 1810, lists his wife Bitradge, his son John, his daughters Jane Milspaugh, Agnes Thompson, Martha White, and Mary Brown, and his grandson Samuel the son of John White. John White and Adam Milspaugh are named as executors of his estate.

J-282: Adam W. Millspaugh, died September 2, 1830, age 26 years, 3 months, 28 days

J-283: Jane, wife of Adam Millspaugh, died June 29, 1812, age 49 years, 1 month, 6 days

J-284: Adam Millspaugh, died April 6, 1821, age 61 years, 2 months, 1 day

Francis C. Millspaugh, The Millspaugh Family in America (1959), p. 104: Born Dec. 21 1759 baptized Jan. 29, 1760. Served as Private in 2nd Regt. Ulster Co., N.Y., Militia in the Revolutionary War. He married Jane White March 13, 1783 who was born Feb. 10, 1763 and died June 27, 1812. He was a farmer at Crystal Run, Orange Co., N.Y. He served as Wallkill Town Supervisor 1810-1815, 1817-1820, 1822. He was widely known as a 7th son and as such, employed to cure "Scroffulla" and "King's Evil". He died April 6, 1824 and is buried with his wife at Scotchtown, N.Y. His will dated March 8, 1824 is on file in Orange Co., N.Y. (Book G, p. 197). His will mentions his eldest son Samuel; his daughters Janet Corwin, Susannah Bailey, Bettridge Vail and Elizabeth Little; his son Peter, his wife Elcy and thier children Adam Nelson and Oliver Bailey; his son Adam White; his grandaughter Nancy Slaughter Millspaugh; his son-in-law Jason Corwin.

J-285 (red sandstone, badly broken)

J-286: Peter Millspaugh, died September 29, 1854, age 69 years, 21 days

J-287: Elsa, wife of Peter Millspaugh, died Nov. 1, 1856, age 63 years, 3 months, 17 days

J-290: In memory of John Millspaugh, died Feb. 19, 1827, age 31 yrs, 6 months, 21 days

J-291: William Millspaugh, died April 10, 1820, age 28 years, 7 months, 14 days

J-292: Nancy, wife of William Millspaugh, died January 11, 1818, age 20 years, 13 days

J-293 (foot stone)

J-294: Samuel M. Vail, died June 16, 1853, age 13 years, 7 months, 3 days

J-295: John Millspaugh, son of Bettridge Vail & [?], died Dec. 1, 1821, age 5 years, 6 days

J-296: Esther, daughter of Daniel & Margaret Reynolds, died June 14, 1815, age 19 years, 5 months, 6 days

J-297: In memory of Theodore, son of Mary & Stephen Reynolds

J-298: In memory of George, son of Steven & Mary Reynolds, died October 31, 1835, age 7 months, 29 days

J-299: Mary, wife of Samuel Myers, died August 30, 1865, age 81 years, 10 months, 22 days

J-300: In memory of Mary Jane, wife of Edward M. Terry, died July 11, 1847, age 25 years,
5 months, 21 days

J-301 (red sandstone): John Fowler, died October 9, 18[??], age 63 years

J-302 (sandstone): Martha, wife of John Fowler, died March 3, 1819, age 50 years

J-303: Melissa, wife of John McGowan, died November 4, 1864, age 59 years, 4 months, 15 days

J-304 (white marble stone, badly broken)

J-305: Adam Crans, died March 1, 1817, age 32 years, 7 months, 24 days
As pants the heart for cooling streams
So thirst his soul for God
While on this earth he did remain
To him he showed reward.

J-306: Eleanor, wife of Adam Crans, died March 5, 1814, age 30 years, 5 months, 6 days
Dear husband do not weep
I am not dead but here do sleep
Within this solid lump of clay
Until the resurrection day
And here my body must remain
Till Christ do call me forth again.

J-307: Elizabeth Young, died November 21, 1811, age 92 years

J-308 (sandstone, broken): Johannes Young, died November [?]

Early Wills of Orange County, NY, vol. 2, page 149: The will of Johannes Young, dated November 7, 1815 and probated December 7, 1815, lists his wife Elizabeth, his sons Jacob, Johannis, Daniel, and Moses, and his daughters Susannah and Mary. Methuselah Baldwin, Joseph Connor, and Phebe Connor are listed as witnesses and Elizabeth Young, Moses Bull Jr., and Daniel Young are named as executors of his estate.

J-309: Moses Young, died December 21, 1838, age 41 years, 9 months, 10 days

J-310: Harriet O., daughter of Moses & Charlotte Young, died Feb. 2, 1810, age 18 years, 9 months

J-311: William, son of Robert & Elizabeth Wallace, died September 6, 1839, age 1 year, 8 days

J-312: In memory of Robert Wallace, died August 8, 1839, age 27 years, 4 months, 23 days

J-313: James P., son of William & Kizia Wallace, died February 9, 1883, age 7 years

J-314: Grave of Elizabeth, daughter of William & Kizia Wallace, died May 1, 1821, age 10 years

J-315: James, son of William & Kizia Wallace, age 5 years, 11 months

J-316: Theodore Wallace, son of William & Kizia Wallace, died December 11, 1846, age 18 years,
5 months, 13 days

J-317: Katherine Lybolt, 1851-1927

J-318: Mary Jane, daughter of Robert & Jane Longheed, died June 8, 183[?]

J-319: Phebe Miller, died April 11, 1877, age 76 years, 11 [months or days]

J-320: Nancy, wife of John Crawford, died October 22, 1857, age 56 years, 11 months, 25 days

J-321: John Crawford, died December 3, 1858, age 72 years

J-322: John Galloway, died September 15, 1851, age 94 years, 3 months

J-323: [?] Galloway, died April 1851, age 62 years, 18 days

J-324: Emma D., died March 15, 1868, age 17 years, 20 days
Albert S., died September 21, 1854, age 1 year, 1 month, 24 days
John E., died November 12, 1862, age 1 year, 8 months
Children of J. T. & G. E. Miller
Cease fond parents, cease to mourn
Remember Jesus said of such, my kingdom is composed
Our children are not dead

J-325: John T. Miller, born 1827, died 1887

K-326: James Connor, died March 8, 1845, age 55 years

K-327: Jemima, wife of James Connor, died December 30, 1863, age 73 years

K-328: Susan Miller, died January 16, 1851, age 77 years

K-329: In memory of Robert Longheed, died October 10, 1843, age 50 years
Mary Longheed, died January 30, 1844, age 1 year, 1 month, 23 days

K-330: In memory of Arthur Johnston, died January 26, 1841, age 65 years
Mary Longheed, wife of Arthur Johnston, died March 3, 1856, age 80 years

K-331: In memory of Jane, wife of Robert Longheed, died Jan. 22, 1842, age 50 years

K-332: William Wallace [?]

K-333: Grave of Rebecca, wife of William Wallace, died October 5, 1829, age 78 years

K-334: Alfred, son of William & Kezia Wallace, died March 22, 1841, age 16 years, 7 months

K-335: Kezia, wife of William Wallace, died September 12, 1842, age 52 years, 2 months, 7 days

K-336: William Wallace, died April 15, 1862, age 84 years, 1 month, 1 day
The memory of the just is blessed

K-337: Mary Wallace, wife of Theron Libolt, died April 9, 1889, age 78 years, 9 months

K-338: In memory of Cherry Ann Young, daughter of Jacob Young, died May 29, 1813, age 19 days

K-339: In memory of Jemuel Corwin, died November 19, 1849, age 62 years

K-340: Susan Corwin, wife of Samuel Corwin, age 35 years, 11 months, 22 days
Daughter Cynthia, age 26 years, died January 27, 1824

K-341: Luther Corwin, son of Jemuel & Susan Corwin, died [?]

K-343: Elizabeth, wife of Jacob Young, died January 21, 1835, age 46 years, 3 months, 6 days

K-345: Jacob Young, died January 19, 1858, age 76 years, 8 months, 27 days

K-346: Roda, wife of Jacob Young, died April 5, 1864, age 78 years

K-347: Frances Amelia, wife of Herman B. Young, died Aug. 10, 1861, age 42 yrs, 3 mths, 26 days
Frank R., only son of Herman and Frances Young, died August 28, 1861, age 21 days

K-348: Jane Ayres, died July 1, 1873, age 71 years, 11 months

K-349: James Andress Ayres, died February 20, 1867, age 74 years

K-350: Julia Ann Ayres, died February 20, 1839, age 24 years

K-351: Sarah Jane, daughter of Stephen & Mary Reynolds, died December 27, 1859, age 18 years,
6 months, 25 days
She died in full hope of after immortality.

The Whig Press (January 18, 1860): Sarah Jane, daughter of Stephen Reynolds of Monticello, died December 27 of a sore throat in Bullville at the age of 18 years.

K-352: In memory of Julia, wife of Enos Ayres, died August 7, 1852, age 78 years

K-353: Enos Ayres, died July 10, 1828, age 61 years, 5 months, 1 day

Early Wills of Orange County, NY, vol. 2, page 259: The will of Enos Ayres, dated September 4, 1827 and probated September 27, 1828, lists his wife July, his sons James Andress, Enos, and William, his daughters Elmira, Hyle, July Ann, and Sarah Crane. Charles H. Mandeville, Simeon T. Bush, and John Laugheed are listed as witnesses and his son-in-law John A. Crane and Enos Ayres Jr. are named as executors of his estate.

K-354: Elmira Ayres, died June 25, 1883, age 78 years, 2 months, 3 days

K-355: Hannah Ayres, died August 15, 1825, age 23 years
But drops of grief in ne’er repay
The debt of love I owe
Here Lord I give myself away
Tis all that I can do

K-356: William Ayres, died February 15, 1838, age 39 years, 11 months, 4 days
He has gone to the mansion of rest
From a region of sorrow and pain
To the glorious land of the blest
Where he never can suffer again

K-357: Susan, wife of William Ayres, died September 24, 1866, age 65

K-358: Oliver Ayres, died May 14, 1879, 53 years, 10 months, 27 days
Rejoicing in hope

K-359: Charles Moore, died June 8, 1807, age 3 years, 26 days

K-360: John Moore, died March 1, 1821, age 21 years, 10 months, 24 days

K-361: In memory of Jane, wife of Amasa Jump, died April 25, 1833, age 66 years

K-362: William H. Decker, Co. F, 4th N.Y.H.A., died March 29, 1899, age 53 years

L-364: Patrick Moran Jr., died September 9, 1852, age 25 years, 4 months

L-366: Charles W. Wall, Co. M, 10th Infantry Regiment, 189[?]-1919

Middletown Times Press (7 Feb. 1919): The funeral of Charles H. Wall was held at 2 o’clock this afternoon at his late home, [53?] Beacon Street. The services were in charge of Rev. Samuel Millar. Internment was in the family plot in Scotchtown.

L-367: Lilly Irene Wall, 1894-1907

L-368: John Wells Hull Smith, died June 30, 1875, age 13 years

L-369: Children of George M. & Malinda A. Smith
G. A. Smith, born 1860, died 1875
M. E. Smith, born 1874, died 1877
G. A. M. Smith, born 1863, died 1864

L-370 (stone badly broken)

L-371: John McLaughlin, died March 21, 1865, age 74 years, 8 months

L-372: In memory of Mary Gilmore, died June 1, 1851, age 56 years, 6 months, 19 days

L-374: Abigail, wife of David Edwards, died February 10, 1831

L-375: David Edwards, died February 13, 1838, age 65 years, 9 months, 27 days

L-376: George F. [?], died December 14, 1867, age 18 years, 9 [months or days]
Nathaniel [?], died July 29, 1873

L-379: Charles J., son of W. & J. McCarter, died 10 years, 9 months

L-380: Moses Steel, died March 14, 1863

L-381: Catherine, wife of Isaac Van Osdales, died April 4, 1856, age 22 yrs, 6 months, 7 days

L-382: Isabelle, wife of Archibald Mahan, died July 29, 1863, age 71 years

L-383: Archibald Mahan, died September 7, 1865, age 81 years

L-384: Mathew Moon, died October 4, 1822, age 39 years, 9 months, 17 days

L-385: Elinor, daughter of Matthew & Margaret Moon, age 7 years, 4 months

L-386: James S. Lynch, 1812-1896
Wife, Mary Ann, 1811-1844
Daughter, Phebe Elizabeth, [?]

L-387: William Hurtin, died April 15, 1834, son of Jacob & Eliza Mills, age 2 years,
8 months, 17 days
Andrew Jackson, son of Jacob & Eliza Mills, age 6 months

L-389: Jacob Mills, died June 3, 1855, age 64, 2 months, 24 days

L-390: Eliza, wife of Jacob Mills, died August 21, 1879, age 76 years, 8 months, 11 days

Federal Mortality Records from the 1880 Census: Died a widow of Neuralgia of the heart. Her physicians were James H. Smiley and Harvey Everett.

L-391: Walter Jackson Hurtin, died January 24, 1809, age 6 months, 16 days

L-392: Susan Marie Hurtin, died March 1814, age 1 year, 1 month
Here her body lies to dust confined
She has left a troubled world behind
And angles will waft her soul to reft
In paradise among the bleft.

L-392A: Elizabeth, wife of William Hurtin, died April 2, 1830, age 59 years, 3 months, 23 days

L-393: William Hurtin, died November 1, 1858, age 87 years, 10 days

L-394: Sally Ann Hurtin, died November 1, 1858, age 79 years

L-395: Adaline Hurtin, wife of Hiram Dunning, born December 25, 1815, died August 30, 1899

L-396: Gilbert Hulse, died January 9, 1817, age 81 years, 3 months, [?] days
The living know that they must die
But all the dead forgotten lie
Their memory and their
[?] is gone
Alike unknowing and unknown.

Early Wills of Orange County, NY, vol. 2, page 160: The will of Gilbert Hulse, dated September 8, 1815 and probated January 17, 1817, lists his wife Charity Hulse, his son Thomas, his daughters Polly Hulse, Lucinda Hulse, Betsy, and Sarah Scofield, and his grandchildren Gilbert Scofield and Gilbert Hulse. Benjamin Hulse, Hannah Crabtree and David R. Arnell are listed as witnesses and Charity Hulse, Thomas Hulse, and Jacob Youngs are named as executors of his estate.

L-397: Mary Hulse, [?] 1862, age 82 years, 1 month, 17 days

L-399: In memory of Thomas Hulse, died November 25, 1817, age 35 years, 3 months, 5 days
Behold and fee as you paff by
As you are now fo once was I
As I am now you foon must be
Prepare yourselves to follow me.

L-400: In memory of Lucinda, wife of Phineas Hulse, died Aug. 31, 1829, age 38 yrs, 1 mth, 3 days

L-401: Phineas Hulse, died March 30, 1846, age 55 years, 8 months

L-402: In memory of James S., son of Phineas Hulse, died August 26, 1846, age 30 years, 28 days

L-403: Sacred to memory of Charity, daughter of Phineas & Lucinda Hulse, died October 12, 1846, age 27 years, 5 months, 27 days

L-405: Mary, daughter of Phineas & Lucinda Hulse, died July 26, 1863, age 29 yrs, 10 mths, 3 days

L-406: Gilbert Hulse, 1820-1899

L-407: Stephen Reynolds, died November 10, 1872, age 71 years, 8 months

L-408: Mary Shafer, wife of Stephen Reynolds, died May 23, 1877, age 74 years, 14 days

L-409: Amelia E. Brown, born August 8, 1830, died April 21, 1901
Gone but not forgotten

L-410: Frankie E. Brown, died May 17, 1880. age 23 years, 11 months, 3 days
Absent but not forgotten

Federal Mortality Records from the 1880 Census: Francis E. Brown, a 25-year-old single white female, died of Malarial fever. Her occupation was listed as "Keeping house". She and her parents were all born in New York and her physician was J. H. Smiley.

L-411: Fanny, wife of Henry W. Miller, died April 20, 1879, age 78 yrs, 10 months, 17 days

L-412: Henry W. Miller, died December 25, 1820, age 23 years, 7 months, 8 days

L-413: James White, died March 1, 1860, age 83 years

L-413A: Abigail, wife of James White, died age 87 years, 8 days

L-414: Phebe Connor, died January 24, 1857, age 73 years

L-415: Frances Connor, born December 25, 1812, died December 8, 1828
Phebe Connor, born October 8, 1821, died October 22, 1822,
daughter of James & Jemmima Connor

Now Safely moor’d my peril o’er
I’ll sing, first in nights diadem
Forever and forever more
The Star, the Star of Bethlehem

Precious in the sight of the Lord is the death of his saints

L-416: Hannah Brown, died August 25, 1829, age 80 years

L-417: John Fergerson, died October 1, 1862, age 72 years

L-418: M. F. age 21 years

M-419: In memory of Phillip Fowler, died March 5, 1810, age 18 years, 1 month, 21 days

M-421: Jane McNeal, died April 16, 1814, age 30 years, [?] months, 1 day
Here lies the body for which I mourn
For God has heard my cry
Ye living men come view the ground
Where you must shortly lie

M-422: Edward, son of James & Nancy McNeal, died Jan. 18, 1812, age 3 years, 4 months, 10 days

M-423: In memory of John Savage, died April 23, 1831, age 60 years, 7 months, 23 days

M-424: In memory of Miriah Miller, daughter of John & Mahetable Savage, died April 1, 1833,
age 23 years, 9 months, 17 days

M-425: David Moore, died May 3, 1808, age 28 years

M-426: James Moore, died April 15, 1799, age 48 years

Early Wills of Orange County, NY, vol. 2, page 42: James Moore’s will, dated April 12, 1799 and probated April 14, 1800, lists his wife Charity, his sons David, William, Henry and James, and his daughters Agnes, Jane and Ann. Hugh Thompson and Bettridge White are listed as witnesses and George Houston and John White are named as executors of his estate.

Charles C. Coleman, Early Marriage Records of the First Presbyterian Church at Goshen: James More married Charity Newkirk on May 14, 1778.

M-427: In memory of Charity, wife of James Moore, died November 16, 1820, age 71 years

M-428: Harrison, son of Henry & Fanny Moore, died July 6, 1827, age 2 years, 10 months, 10 days

M-429: H. Smith [??]

M-430: I. Smith [??]

M-431: In memory of William, son of Henry & Fanny Moore, died February 1, 1838, age 15 years

M-432: In memory of James Welson, son of Fanny & Henry Moore, died February 1, 1838,
age 5 years, 9 months, 8 days

M-433: William Moore, died November 27, 1816, age 56 years

M-434: James Williamson, died September 10, 1822, age 1 year, 1 month

Edward B. Fix, "In a Carpenter's Own Words: Letters of Seth Williamson, 1810-1835" in The Chronicle of the Early American Industries Association, Inc.: "I thought proper to inform you of the situation of myself and family. At the present we are in tolerable health but on the 12th of this instant we lost our youngest son James Hervey Williamson. He was taken sick on Sunday afternoon and died on Wednesday night just before day light. It is very sickly in this part of our country. There is a burying almost every day. Denton Mills has lost his youngest child. John Smith son of old Uncle Selah Smith in Sctaukct has lost a son and daughter and grandchild....Mr Sears daughter Polly Roe lies very low at present with the disentary. You can inform our friends of the death of our child."

M-435: Anne, died July 1, 1823, daughter of Seth & Catherine Williamson, age 15 years, 10 months

M-436: Catherine, wife of Seth Williamson, died August 25, 1825, age 44 years, 5 months, 22 days

Edward B. Fix, "In a Carpenter's Own Words: Letters of Seth Williamson, 1810-1835" in The Chronicle of the Early American Industries Association, Inc.: "It is with a heavy heart and trembling hands I undertake to inform you of the heavy affliction I am under. My wife was buried at nine o clock this morning. She has left an infant son five weeks and three days old. The mail is now waiting which oblidgees me to close without informing you of the particulares of her death. I wish you to inform father and all my friends of my heavy affliction." ... A couple of months later, Seth notified his brother John that "I have a Mrs Smith keeping house for me, a very tender hearted fine woman among children." Within a year, another letter cautiously announced his marriage to Julia Smith: "I suppose you have heard before this that I have taken another companion. Whether I have made a wise choice or not time must determine. I was under the absolute necessity of marrying again or breaking up house keeping. My girls was not old enough to take care of business and hiring house keepers will not do...."

M-437: Julia, wife of Seth Williamson, died January 7, 1835, age 50 years, 10 months, 8 days

Edward B. Fix, "In a Carpenter's Own Words: Letters of Seth Williamson, 1810-1835" in The Chronicle of the Early American Industries Association, Inc.: Beginning in Beginning in 1830, Seth's second wife, Julia, endured a five-year battle with an apparent cancerous growth on her foot which eventually cost her her life: "My wife about 7 weeks ago had a small sore come on top of the right foot. I was fearfull it was the arrisipus but her applying cooling things kept it from spreading and inflaming for some time. The doctor was sent for who pronounced it arrisipus which has been considerably advancing over the systems. At present it seems to conflnd to the foot the side of the right foot at the root of the little toe is the worst. The foot is very much inflamd up to the ankle. The doctor spoke quite encouraging yesterday respecting it but is so fearfull she will loose her little toe....How long she may remain in this situation I cannot tell and what may be the consequence." A week later, Seth wrote John M. again and solemnly mentioned, "I dont know that my wife is any better whether she will loose her life or foot I cant tell at present." Within a couple more weeks, a very worried Seth remarked to John M. that "the complaint seems to be running all over her. I dont expect she will walk any on her foot this winter if ever. I dont know hardly what to write. I dont think her out of danger by any means....I have employed two doctors. I am in haste....You must excuse me in not writing any more." A next letter, over a year later, talked about the "sorrowful time" due to "influenza" and briefly noted that "my wifes health is quite feeble." The apparent cancer took Julia's life in January 1835: "Providence hath deprived me of my companion. She was as well as usual last Christmas noon and cat dinner as well as common and in the afternoon was taken with a pain in her side and at dark laid down. Lettyann applyed warm things to her side but all to no purpose. The next day the doctor was cald and hied her and give her physic. Hut the complaint was very obstenate. Medicine did not opperate as the doctor would wish. The fifth day after she was taken she appeared rather better but the typhus fever set in and she died....Theophilus Smith and Maria come from Milford the Sunday previous to her death and staid untill she was buried."

M-438: John McWilliams, died November 23, 1802, age 77 years

Early Wills of Orange County, NY, vol. 2, page 54: The will of John McWilliams, dated October 5, 1798 and probated December 8, 1802, lists his wife Sarah, his sons John, James (minor), and Andrew and his daughters Elizabeth, Agnes, and Isabella. He also names his son-in-law Kaleb Goldsmith. Patrick Bodle, William Bodle and Isaac Tallmady are listed as witnesses and Andrew McWilliams is named as executor of his estate.

Nancy McWillaims Bible: John McWilliams and Sarah Haffy came to America from Scotland and purchased a farm in Scotchtown in 1785.

National Society of the Daughters of the American Revolution, Vol. 117, page 145: John McWilliams (1725-1802) served as private in Lieut. Col. Marinus Willit's regiment, New York Line, Capt. Lawrence Gross' company. He was born in Scotland; died in Scotchtown, N.Y.

Memorial and Family History of Erie County, New York (Genealogical Publishing Co., 1906): "The McWilliams family is of Scotch origin. The founder of its American branch was John McWilliams, who was born in Scotland, came to this country at a period near the Revolution, and settled in Long Island, afterward removing to Scotchtown, N.Y. The wife of John McWilliams was Sally Haffee."

M-439: Sarah McWilliams, died May 6, 1801, age 65 years


These records were compiled in July of 1962 by C. A. Comfort and I. J. Gibbs. For the sake of clarity their punctuation has been changed slightly and some terms that were abbreviated on the grave monuments have been spelled out in full. Additional information I have found appears in blue. Long inscriptions, typically quotes from the bible or short poems, are italicized. Question marks in brackets indicate where the inscriptions (or the record of Gibbs and Comfort) are unclear or illegible.